italian version

Woke and Progressivism

 

 

Pubblicato da https://www.americacallsitaly.org/in  WOKE    7 novembre 2026   

 

 

Giovanni De Sio Cesari                                                        

www.giovannidesio.it

 

 

The Woke movement seems to be in crisis, according to its own supporters, who are therefore speaking of Woke 2. But the difference would concern not its goal, but only the means of achieving it.

The problem, however, lies in its basic character, which is an expression of a certain view of reality that is simplistic and ahistorical.

Certain principles, sometimes merely theoretical and not fully realized in our culture, appear to be absolute, and people fail to recognize their problematic nature, the fact that we do not know absolute truth, but that every theory can be called into question. On the other hand, if these principles were not recognized in the past for so many millennia, does that mean that all our ancestors were foolish and/or evil? And people fail to realize that material and cultural conditions change over time.

To give an example: according to feminism, there are males and females (that is, distinguished only by different sexual organs), but not men and women with different personalities and roles. But are we really so sure that this is true? Is there no difference between mothers and fathers, between husbands and wives, apart from their sexual organs? I am not giving an answer, but merely saying that these are complex and debatable questions, which can and should be discussed.

Similarly, are we supposed to think that in the past all men were bad because they oppressed women? Is it really true that women were unhappy before and are happy now? We must also realize that feminism became possible thanks to technological progress: without modern means and with high infant mortality, how could women possibly have devoted themselves to anything other than the home and children?

Likewise, as soon as cultural differences are noticed, people start talking about racism. But is it really wrong to think that people belonging to Islamic culture think differently from those belonging to Christian culture, regardless of whether they are believers or not? Or that, in the past, among the upper classes, a woman was not even struck with a flower, whereas among the popular classes, perhaps a man who never beat his wife might have seemed less of a man?

Undoubtedly, it is wrong to apply our criteria to the past. But there is another, more serious mistake made by Woke: confusing what is new with progress and, so to speak, with what is good. That is not the case.

Traditions are innovations from the past that have proved to be valid and might (though they need not) cease to be so in a different context.

Here are a few examples:

In politics, democracies are an innovation that replaced absolutist systems ruling by divine right, which have disappeared from history. But fascism, communism, and the political illusions of 1968 also presented themselves as innovations: they have all been superseded by history, while the democratic tradition has reasserted itself.

Racism (in the strict genetic sense) also emerged as an innovation at the end of the nineteenth century, but it was later superseded and even became a moral fault.

Positivism transformed the way people thought by asserting that only science could grasp absolute truth, but after a few decades the relativity of scientific truths became established and, above all, the inapplicability of this approach to human affairs.

Woke, on the other hand, claims that certain innovations are the definitive and absolute truth and therefore cannot be called into question.

If we take for granted that overcoming racism, the evolution of women’s roles, a new sexual morality, and the acceptance of homosexuals are good or bad a priori, without allowing discussion of their meaning, limits, and positive and negative aspects, then we will have a WOKE of the left or of the right. But the terms right and left themselves (like all political terms) are used to indicate very different things.

It should be noted that, in general terms, these principles are also accepted on the right, albeit with some reservations and limitations.

What is important, in my opinion, is that these issues must be discussed and that discussion must not be prohibited, as WOKE does.

Sometimes it is claimed that certain modern principles are validated by science and therefore cannot be questioned.

But current theories of science state that science does not provide definitive answers: something is scientifically true if, UP TO NOW, it has not been falsified, but it could subsequently be falsified. For example, until Einstein, no one thought that time and space were relative, and Einstein’s theory will be considered true until, if ever, it is falsified.

The falsification of racism is particularly difficult: it is difficult to apply natural science to human affairs.

In general, what is considered scientific is accepted: only a small group of scientists could call it into question. When, on the other hand, there are differing opinions, it means that there is no genuine scientific evidence (although scientific evidence is never definitive). No one really questions the speed of light (or geocentrism), and only a few scientists in the relevant field could do so. But the idea that some peoples were genetically superior to others was considered scientific from the late nineteenth century onward, whereas in modern times the opposite view has prevailed: in reality, there is no genuine scientific evidence for it.

Let us say that Woke, while presenting itself as democratic, is actually opposed to democracy because it excludes from discussion and critical examination everything that is contrary to the ideas currently prevailing, or presumed to be prevailing.

Woke is a radicalization of political correctness.

I would say that both are anti-democratic because they limit freedom of expression (which is different from freedom of action), a pillar of democracy.

If someone wants to claim that Black people are genetically inferior, they must have the freedom to say so: they will then be overwhelmed by ridicule and criticism, or perhaps not. That is democracy.

As for the Overton window: it is said that in every society there are ideas that are generally rejected, excluded, and considered wrong and/or immoral, which is undoubtedly true. However, in a democracy, we must also allow ideas that are not generally accepted, because that is how change becomes possible.

Returning to an earlier example, people once generally believed that Black people were genetically inferior; then the idea that this was not true became established, and now this idea has become dominant and has driven the opposing idea outside the Overton window. But we must not exclude the possibility that the opposite could happen again.

To avoid misunderstandings, it is not that I generally disagree with the progressive ideas I mentioned earlier. Rather, I believe that what is new does not always endure (progress), but can also be superseded by history, as in the examples I gave.

If I am absolutely opposed to racism, I cannot, however, rule out the possibility that it might actually be true. If someone were to advocate racism, I would then have to examine the scientific and/or non-scientific arguments if I want to be scientific and democratic.

I am in favor of what can be called a historical, that is, realistic, approach, which rejects utopia—that is, something that has never been achieved because, although desirable, it is impossible to achieve.

The Woke approach bans and rejects any confrontation with opposing opinions, which are defined as non-progressive.

What does progressivism mean?

For example, is sexual freedom, as opposed to sexuality limited to the married couple, progress or regression? It depends on one’s point of view and on the principles one adopts.

And what about the idea that whatever is new is good and right, while tradition is evil and toxic? These questions, however, need to be examined.

I believe instead that freedom (when actually realized), the foundation of democracy (when actually practiced), is the possibility of expressing one’s own opinions: saying that something cannot be said because it is fascist, communist, patriarchal, unconstitutional, backward, etc., etc., is contrary to democratic freedom.

We should not idealize the past, but neither should we idealize the present: we must strive to see them as they really are (the historical approach, as I said).